Trade unions should use their place in the Labour Party, not give it up, argues Jeff Slee.
Support is growing for a campaign, led by some on the trade union left, for unions to leave the Labour Party – to disaffiliate from it. Those campaigns will grow stronger if Burnham as PM turns out to be much the same as Starmer, but with a friendly northern face; if doesn’t do what he promised to Labour Conference: to “break with the direction of the past 40 years”, which he said was “Deindustrialisation. Deregulation. Privatisation. Austerity. Brexit.”
The campaign for disaffiliation has already had an impact in some unions. Earlier this year, Unite cut its affiliation to Labour by 40% and launched a formal consultation with members about whether to stay affiliated at all. General Secretary Sharon Graham seems not to be wholeheartedly committed either to affiliation or disaffiliation. There were also proposals to this year’s Unison and CWU conferences for disaffiliation, which had significant support.
In this century, the Labour Party has lost some of its affiliated unions. The RMT left in 2004, after it started supporting Scottish Socialist Party candidates in elections. The BFAWU disaffiliated in 2021because of its opposition to Starmer’s policies. The FBU disaffiliated in 2004 because of its opposition to Blair’s government, but rejoined in 2015 to support Jeremy Corbyn, and remains affiliated.
Leaving the Labour Party would be a wrong move. Affiliated trade unions do have power and a formal role in the Party, and we should be campaigning for them to use this for their members, for workers of the world, and for socialist policies. Disaffiliation leads either to pursuing the failed path to some sort of new workers’ party, or to a retreat from politics.
Trade unions and Labour
As everyone knows, trade unions together with early socialists created the Labour Party at the start of the 20th century and have been an integral part of the Party ever since. Unions have contributed some of the worst of the Party’s leadership throughout its history. To give three examples (two of whom – to our shame – came from my own union):
- JH Thomas, General Secretary of the NUR 1916-1931, was also a Labour MP (NUR rules were later changed to stop our union officers also being MPs). He was a Cabinet member in the 1924 and 1929-31 Labour governments under Ramsay MacDonald, and in 1931 betrayed the Party by going with MacDonald into coalition with the Conservatives and Liberals in the National Government – against the wishes of the Labour Party, most of whom opposed that coalition.
- Ernest Bevin, still a hero to many on the right of the Party, had been General Secretary of the TGWU. He was very anti-Communist and pro-imperialist in the unions as well as the Party, and one of the TUC General Council leaders who betrayed the 1926 General Strike. He was Foreign Secretary in Labour’s 1945 government and in that post was one of the key figures in the founding of NATO and the start of the Cold War.
- John Prescott, Labour’s Deputy Leader under Tony Blair and Deputy Prime Minister1997-2007, came from the NUS, the seafarers, which in 2000 merged with the NUR to form the RMT. Despite being an RMT-sponsored MP, he argued successfully for the Labour leadership at the 1997 Party Conference against a motion proposing that the Labour government should renationalise rail. Prescott also served as Blair’s cover to the unions and the left in the Party including, for example, supporting involvement in the war against Iraq in 2003.
Unions have also contributed some of the best Labour MPs. In the present Parliament, for example, the Socialist Campaign Group includes Kate Osborne who was previously among the left on Unite’s Executive Council, and Ian Lavery who was President of the NUM.
So those who argue that it’s right-wing Labour leaderships who hold back left-wing affiliated unions are just plain wrong about the history.
What does affiliation to the Labour Party mean?
Eleven of the 48 TUC unions are affiliated to the Labour Party. These include Unison, Unite, the GMB, CWU, and USDAW – five of the largest unions in the UK, representing between them about 3 ½ million of the 5 ½ million TUC members.
Affiliated organisations – almost all being trade unions – have 50% of the votes on resolutions at Labour Party Conference. At the 2025 and 2026 Party Conferences, they used this to carry motions moved by unions including ones for a full arms embargo on Israel, an end to UK-Israel military cooperation and a recognition that Israel’s policy towards Palestine constitutes genocide; for wealth taxes and an end to austerity; and for a second Employment Rights Bill.
The trade unions have 13 places out of 41 on the Party National Executive Committee (NEC), which administers the Party, plus the Party Treasurer who always comes from the unions.
Anyone standing for election as Leader or Deputy Leader of the Labour Party must be nominated by at least two unions. When Jeremy Corbyn won the election for Labour Leader in 2015, he had been nominated by Unite, Unison, TSSA, BFAWU, and FBU. In some of these unions, that nomination was the result of grassroots pressure, not leadership enthusiasm.
So the affiliated unions do not just give large sums of money to the Labour Party and in return get told what to do by the Party leadership. They are an integral part of what the Party is. Of its record, of its history. And of all its faults – the things that it has done which socialists have opposed throughout its history, and the many things that it should have done but didn’t. And, potentially, they could be integral to the transformation of the Party into one that is unequivocally on the side of the working class and the oppressed people of the world.
Instead of pulling away from the Labour Party, affiliated unions should be encouraging their members to be more involved in their local Constituency Labour Parties – including through affiliating union branches to local Labour Parties – and providing the political education to help them be more effective there. They should be using that involvement in selections of Labour candidates for Parliament, with the aim of changing the Parliamentary Labour Party for the better.
Leaders of the eleven affiliated trade unions meet with Party leaders in a group called ‘Labour Unions’ – the Trade Union and Labour Party liaison organisation, formerly called TULO.
It is because of Labour Unions that we got one of the few positives from the Starmer government: the Employment Rights Act 2025. Now there are justified criticisms of this Act from the left in the union movement. I have written about the Act and explained, and supported, these criticisms in articles on this website. Others have written about how the Act, and the New Deal for Working People on which it is based, fall short of the plans for workers’ and trade union rights that were drawn up under Jeremy’s leadership. But Labour’s claim that this Act is the greatest step forward for workers’ rights in a generation is also true. Also true is the unwritten implication of this claim: that this government has done more to improve workers’ and trade union rights than the New Labour government did in 13 years of government.
And getting the New Deal for Working People agreement, getting a commitment to it into Labour’s 2024 general election manifesto, and then getting it into one of the first of the Starmer government’s Bills, was largely due to the efforts of the affiliated trade unions working through TULO.
Probably the only other worthwhile achievement of Starmer’s government is renationalisation of rail. New Labour refused to reverse the Tory privatisation of rail throughout the 1997-2010 government. The affiliated rail unions – ASLEF and TSSA – campaigned and won the support of Labour Conference for renationalisation and made it Labour policy. This policy was then put into detailed form under the guidance of Andy MacDonald MP when he was Shadow Transport Secretary under Jeremy’s leadership, and on the basis of that policy the Labour government included renationalisation in its first King’s Speech.
These two examples show that trade unions, by being affiliated to the Labour Party and working within it, can and do influence Labour’s leadership, policies, and practice to produce improvements for working people and trade unions.
Those leading campaigns for disaffiliation misrepresent (knowingly?) the relationship between affiliated unions and Labour. They argue that affiliated unions have no influence over Labour’s policies, its practice, or its leadership. For example, the Socialist Party’s newspaper of 24th June this year – reporting on efforts to get disaffiliation debated at Unison AGM said:
“If Unison… had a true influence on Labour, or if any of the affiliated unions did, then the Labour government would have scrapped Tory anti-trade union laws, enacted a real living wage, built council homes, renationalised services, and Unite wouldn’t have cut its affiliation fees by 40%.”
But, as I have shown, they are wrong. Affiliated unions do have a true influence on Labour. Affiliated unions have always been part of Labour’s leadership, its policies and practice. The problem has been with the way that influence has been used, and the times it should have been used for workers but wasn’t. And this comes down to the trade unions themselves, to the union leaderships, and to the need for socialists and militants to fight within unions – not to the relationship between unions and Labour.
Socialists in affiliated trade unions should be holding to account those who represent them on Labour’s NEC, who for the most part did not support left NEC members in opposing the expulsions and suspensions of Party members, and selection-rigging that took place under Starmer’s leadership. For example, when the Gorton and Denton by-election was called earlier this year, an NEC subcommittee decided by 8 to 1 not to allow Andy Burnham to be a contender for Labour’s candidate in that by-election. The only vote for Andy came from Lucy Powell, on the subcommittee as Deputy Leader. That subcommittee had ten members, including three from the unions: Mike Payne (GMB union) in his role as Party Treasurer; Keiran O’Neill (GMB); and Tom Williams (USDAW). All three voted against Andy Burnham being allowed to stand.
What is the alternative to affiliation?
Some – especially the Socialist Party – who campaign for disaffiliation propose that trade unions should, instead, help create a new party based on the working class. They should explain to us why none of the attempts by socialists to create a party to the left of Labour, based on the working class, has yet succeeded. They should also explain why they have been so unsuccessful in persuading unions – and remember, most trade unions are not affiliated to the Labour Party and never have been – to put their weight behind any of these attempts.
In this century alone there have been several failed attempts. In one way, this is a shame, because it has meant that the time, effort, and commitment given by good socialist comrades to these attempts has been wasted.
The Scottish Socialist Party, set up in 1998 by former supporters of the Militant newspaper, appeared at first to have a lot going for it. It was led by Tommy Sheridan, a charismatic figure and great speaker who was well known and highly admired in Scotland for his leading role in the campaign against the Poll Tax there and for supporting workers’ struggles. It started with an organised base of Marxist activists from Militant. It quickly won support from some leading trade union militants and Scottish socialists, and the affiliation of the RMT. In 2003 it got 6.7 % of the votes in the Regional List section of the Scottish Parliament election, which won them six seats in Holyrood. But the next year Sheridan resigned as SSP convenor because it was becoming publicly known that he had a wide-ranging and busy sexual life outside his marriage, including with a News of the World journalist (a 2012 statement by the SSP’s youth section on what went wrong with the SSP labelled Sheridan a “mad shagger”). The internal row around this almost destroyed the SSP and it has not been a significant force in Scotland since.
George Galloway’s Workers Party has won the odd by-election but failed miserably in many more, and has not created anything beyond keeping Galloway’s own personality in the public eye.
Arthur Scargill, one of the greatest trade unionists in the history of the British working class, leader of the 1984-5 miners’ strike, created the Socialist Labour Party in 1996. But it has too has never amounted to anything.
The Socialist Party launched the Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition (TUSC) in 2010, with some support from the RMT union under its then General Secretary Bob Crow. It is still going but has never achieved anything.
And now we have Your Party, set up by Jeremy Corbyn and Zara Sultana with the support of a few other independent MPs and of a strong team including some who had worked with Jeremy when he was Labour leader, and others with a long and honourable record in the labour movement backing it. It started promisingly, with an online campaign that resulted in 600,000 wanting to become founding members. What has happened? It has been brought down already by division between Zara Sultana and those around her, and those supporting Jeremy, and many of those who at first welcomed it – including for example Jamie Driscoll, former Labour Mayor of North Tyneside – have walked away. Your Party did not even manage to stand candidates in the local elections in May.
For 25 years at least, good socialists have been – wrongly – saying that the Labour Party is ‘dead’ (their word) and the time is right to build a new socialist party of the working class. And for all that time their efforts have come to naught. Anyone still pushing this argument must at least explain why this is so, what they have learnt from those experiences, and how they intend to get it right next time.
But if a campaign for disaffiliation does not propose the creation of a new party, then it becomes an argument for a retreat from politics. It means withdrawing from a Party where affiliated unions do have the possibility – even if, by and large, they do not use it – of advocating and voting for pro-working class and socialist policies and leadership, to a position where those unions can campaign and lobby political parties but have no institutional rights to affect policy, or candidates for Parliament and other public offices, and have no more political influence than US trade unions have over the Democrat Party. This would in practice mean pandering to the views of those trade unionists who do not want to be linked to the Labour Party for all the wrong reasons, such as those – including some who are good militants and union reps in their own workplaces – who don’t back Labour because they think it is too ‘woke’, or too ‘soft on immigration’.
Conclusion
Those who campaign for unions to leave the Labour Party, to disaffiliate, are wrong. We should oppose any such moves. Those campaigners may share the widespread disillusionment with the Party since 2019 (a disillusionment also felt by many still in the Party), or they may – like the Socialist Party – see disaffiliation as a route to increasing the size and influence of their small sects.
Remember that many Party members, and the RMT and (from 2004 to 2015) FBU, left the Party in disillusionment when Blair was Leader. The effect of this was that, when Jeremy was elected leader in 2015, the Party at all levels and in all sections was controlled by the right wing, who used their base to continually undermine and attack Jeremy. If those members and unions had stayed in the Party, we would have been in a stronger position to give him the support he needed but which was lacking when he became leader, and maybe history would have been different and better as a result.
The Labour Party is far from ‘dead’, whether we like it or not. And – despite the clampdown on internal democracy and accountability that has taken place since 2019, it is still an arena in which the struggle of our class against the political representatives of the ruling class takes place.
In 2017, with Jeremy as Party leader and John McDonnell as Shadow Chancellor – both great friends of the RMT – I and a few others launched a campaign within the RMT to reaffiliate to Labour. John even came to Exeter to speak at a fringe meeting we held at the RMT Conference there. The issue went to consultation throughout the union, in which Regional Councils and branches debated the issue and split about 50-50 on the question. A Special General Meeting in Doncaster in 2018 voted to support our NEC’s recommendation to stay outside the Party, because there was not a clear majority in the union for a change.
Some of the arguments we put in our campaign then are worth repeating now:
“A class struggle is taking place in the Labour Party. The outcome is vital for our members, for the future of trades unionism and for the working class. RMT cannot sit on the sidelines.
“Workers organised in trade unions can fight and win better jobs, pay, and conditions. But we need working class political representation to stop employers taking away what we win. Trade unions need a political party to stand in elections and win state power. Only the power to make the laws that govern us can give trade unions the legal right to call strikes, bargain collectively for our members, and represent them as our rule book and policies demand.
“If RMT does not affiliate, then RMT members will in effect have to rely on Labour-affiliated unions, such as TSSA, ASLEF, GMB and Unite to hold the line on the policies we support. Are we happy to subcontract political representation of our members to these organisations? RMT members need political representation in their own right, as members of a Labour affiliated union, fighting for socialist policies. RMT members need RMT representatives speaking for us at every level in the Labour Party and that means affiliation.
“The outcome of the political battles taking place in the Labour Party is critical for all our members, for the future of trade unionism and for the whole working class. RMT’s rightful place is shoulder to shoulder with those in the Labour Party fighting for the interests of our members and our class.
“The best way to challenge and replace Labour MPs who oppose Jeremy, and local Labour councillors who implement DOO [Drive Only Operation] or cut local services, is from inside the Labour Party. Inside the Labour Party we can challenge, argue against, hold to account, and seek to replace these MPs and councillors. Outside the Party, we are limited to supporting token, no-hoper, candidates (including TUSC), in election campaigns that last six weeks every four years and are then forgotten. This is not a political strategy.”
Jeff Slee is a retired rail worker and former RMT National Executive Committee member.
Image: https://www.flickr.com/photos/skuds/3736995016 Creator: Andrew Skudder Licence: Attribution-ShareAlike 2.0 Generic CC BY-SA 2.0 Deed
